logo.png

What Making Apple Cider at Home Taught Me About Selling Commodities

Thursday, November 12, 2026

The Digital Marketing Buzz/Marketing Tips/What Making Apple Cider at Home Taught Me About Selling Commodities

A lesson from the cider press

What making apple cider at home taught me about why people pay for experiences, not products.

I used to own an apple orchard. Every fall, I put up about 10 gallons of cider. It started as a chore and turned into a tradition.

When I moved away, the tradition came with me. It takes about 20 lbs of apples to make one gallon of cider, so it was never exactly cost-effective. I did it anyway.

This year, nostalgia hit hard. I wanted to make two gallons: one plain, and one turned into hard cider.

The hour-long drive

So I got in the car and drove about an hour to a U-pick orchard. Seconds (the bruised and damaged apples, perfect for cider) were priced at $1.25 per lb.

Then I saw the line. The fields were full, and the wait to go pick was about an hour.

An hour of driving, plus an hour of waiting, to pay $1.25/lb for damaged fruit. I wasn't willing to do it.

Running the numbers at the grocery store

Instead of waiting, I checked the local grocery stores. Here is what 20 lbs of apples, enough for one gallon, would cost:

Costco

$0.98/lb = $19.60

Stepp's U-pick

$1.22/lb = $24.40

Harris Teeter (bagged Gala)

$1.66/lb = $33.20

Publix

$2.00/lb = $40.00

Finished gallon of cider, grocery store

$7.00

Cost of 20 lbs of apples at each store, versus a ready-made gallon.

Even at Costco, making cider costs nearly three times what a finished gallon does. Unless you own an apple tree, making your own is not cost-effective.

The puzzle

Here is what stopped me. Premium, unblemished apples at the grocery store were actually cheaper than the U-pick seconds.

Better fruit, lower price, no line, no drive.

So why were so many people lined up for an hour to pick their own?

The drive home, with zero apples

I will admit it: I drove an hour, and came home with exactly zero apples. Not my finest efficiency moment.

But somewhere on that drive home, it clicked. Those people in line weren't buying apples.

It's not the apples. The apples are the benefit. The experience is what they're purchasing.

The field. The family outing. The tradition. The nostalgia. The apples are just the souvenir you carry home to prove you were there.

And honestly? That is exactly why I was there too. I just forgot to be honest with myself about it.

The marketing lesson

When you sell a commodity, the experience is all you have

An apple is an apple. You can buy one almost anywhere, often cheaper and better looking. If you sell something that could be a commodity, the experience around it is the only thing that sets you apart.

The businesses that understand this are everywhere:

  • Coffee shops sell a place to belong, not just hot water and beans.
  • Pumpkin patches sell the hayride and the photo, not the pumpkin.
  • Farm-to-table restaurants sell the story behind the plate.
  • Craft breweries sell the taproom and the community.
  • A great local hardware store sells the person who walks you to aisle 7 and tells you exactly what you need.

Questions to ask about your own business

Try these the next time you look at your product page:

Key questions

  • What is the experience around my product?
  • What is my customer really buying?
  • How can I make the experience the thing they talk about?

If you can answer those honestly, you stop competing on price. And you stop caring that the grocery store has cheaper apples.

As for me, I still want that cider. Maybe next year I will wait in the line. Making cider at home was never about saving money. It was about the experience, and so is almost everything worth selling.
​
​Oh and I did plant an apple tree, but it won't bear fruit for a few more years...

Enjoyed this post?

Subscribe to the blog for more marketing insights.

Tim Hewitt, Author

Tim is a Freelance Digital Marketer who specializes in helping other marketers to find ways to earn online. When you are frustrated with your prior efforts, Tim will help you find the way!

Copyright © 2026, The Digital Marketing Buzz | All Rights Reserved.